At 6:23 pm on Thursday, Kevin sits in his office with 2 documents open side by side on his laptop.
On the left of his screen is an onboarding form he filled in 8 weeks ago for a marketing agency in Sheffield (the 3rd agency he’s hired in the past 8 months).
On the right is the agency’s persona slide, presented to him this week.
They describe his ideal customer in 7 points. Kevin reads the 7 points, then the form he filled in, and every point’s a reworded answer he gave to the agency.
Kevin described his ideal customer on the form as, “Head chefs at independent restaurants and hotels in the North.”
With not even a hum from the machines in his workshop, Kevin sits alone, contemplating whether he’s going to need to hire another agency in a few months…
Kevin’s the Business Owner of a 17-person stainless steel fabrication workshop in Attercliffe, Sheffield.
His workshop builds prep tables, sinks and wall shelving for commercial kitchens, and sells all of it through 2 catering equipment dealers.
Every table, sink and shelf is cut from 304 stainless steel (the grade most fabricators use for surfaces that touch food), and, for every job, Kevin’s office keeps
-
the steel mill’s inspection certificate (BS EN 10204:2004, type 3.1), which ties each sheet, by the cast number stamped on the sheet, back to the mill that made the steel,
-
and Kevin’s written declaration that each piece meets the rules for materials that touch food (Regulation (EC) No 1935/2004).
In catering equipment, the dealer owns the customer, so for 6 years Kevin assumed his dealers knew the kitchens and he never needed to.
His workshop’s shipped 4,318 units to 2 dealer addresses and Kevin has never met 1 of the head chefs he described on the form.
So tonight he can’t tell whether any of the 7 points on the agency’s slide is correct.
9 months ago the dealer that took 64% of Kevin’s workshop’s output cut their orders to stock cheaper imports.
The dealer’s last order ships late January, and from then on, Kevin has to let 9 people go, because there won’t be enough work to support all 17.
After the dealer cut their orders, Kevin decided his business would sell their own range direct to kitchens, with no dealer in between.
He’s never sold to a kitchen himself, so in March he hired a marketing agency to find the kitchens for him.
At the first meeting the agency asked Kevin who his ideal customer was, and Kevin answered with a guess (the same line he later typed into the Sheffield form).
Each agency held him to a 3-month minimum contract, and he’s had to hire 3 agencies… so far.
-
The 1st agency, in Leeds, from March–May, built its strategy on Kevin’s guess.
-
The 2nd agency, in Manchester, from June–August, built a new strategy on the same guess.
-
And the 3rd agency, in Sheffield, from September, turned the same guess into the 7-point persona slide.
Kevin told himself the Leeds agency had been a bad fit and the next agency would be different. And after the Manchester agency, he told himself the same thing.
Since March, Kevin’s paid £48,500 across the 3 agencies, and he only has 2 orders from kitchens to show for it.
Tonight, with the form and the slide side by side, Kevin can see the 3 agencies weren’t 3 bad fits in a row.
Each agency expected Kevin to bring the prospect and Kevin expected each agency to find the prospect.
Each agency can honestly say they delivered to the brief, but every brief was built on Kevin’s guess.
And a 4th agency in a few months would probably use the same guess. A better answer on the same form would still be a guess, from a man who’s never met 1 of the head chefs he describes.
The one thing Kevin can’t do alone is find out who really buys his equipment, from research rather than his own guess.
And he has to know before the dealer’s last order.
Your Competitive Edge Blueprint™ starts with the work most marketing agencies assume you’ve already done: who really buys your product, and why?
Your research identifies
-
who buys your product, from data analysed in your business sector,
-
what your prospects have already tried, and rejected,
-
the exact words your prospects use to describe their problem to a colleague over a beer at the pub,
-
and what you can say that no other firm in your sector’s saying so you win the customer.
Once you know who buys your product and why, every marketing approach you take focuses precisely on the prospects most likely to buy, using the words your prospect uses so it resonates instantly.
But Kevin doesn’t do this. Kevin’s convinced a 4th agency will find the kitchens for him.
In December, he hires a 4th agency and types the same guess into the agency’s form.
In late January, the dealer’s last order heads out the door, and Kevin has to tell 9 team members to find work somewhere else.
If you already know your answer to “Who’s your ideal customer?” is going to be a guess, stop.
Build your Competitive Edge Blueprint™ and get to know your prospect as well as you know your product.